speakeater.
Preview This is a new page in the Speakeater sauces collection. The ratio and method are verified against the classic public-domain source cited below. Final kitchen testing and original food photography are still in progress.
Cold sauce . 1:1:1 . dip, dressing, glaze

Honey Mustard.

Equal thirds of three jars you already own. The chicken-tender economy runs on this.

Type
Cold sauce
Base
Honey + Dijon + mayo
Ratio
1:1:1
Time
2 min
Yield
3/4 cup
Quick answer

To make honey mustard, whisk a quarter cup each of honey, Dijon mustard, and mayonnaise with a teaspoon of lemon juice or vinegar and a pinch of cayenne. For dressing, thin with a tablespoon of vinegar and two of oil, for a glaze, leave the mayo out.

What it is

What is honey mustard?

Honey mustard is a balance exercise: sweetness against mustard heat, with mayonnaise as the diplomat that binds them into a dip. Equal thirds is the memorable starting point, and the adjustments are personal, more Dijon for grown-ups, more honey for the kids\u2019 end of the table, a pinch of cayenne to keep the sweetness honest.

Its range is why it earns a jar of its own in the fridge. Un-thinned it is the chicken-tender dip. Whisked with vinegar and oil it dresses spinach and grain bowls. Without the mayo it is a glaze that caramelizes beautifully on chicken, salmon, and ham in the last minutes of heat.

The recipe

What goes in honey mustard?

1/4 cup
Honey
×
1/4 cup
Dijon
×
1/4 cup
Mayonnaise

One to one to one, then tune. Coarse-grain mustard swaps in for texture, yellow mustard reads more ballpark, hot English mustard turns it into a wing sauce.

Method

How do you make honey mustard?

  1. Whisk the honey, Dijon, and mayonnaise until fully smooth.
  2. Add the lemon and cayenne, whisk again.
  3. Rest fifteen minutes if you can, the mustard settles into the honey.
  4. Keeps two weeks refrigerated, stir before use.
One ratio, three sauces Dip, dressing, glaze, all the same two spoonfuls of memory: equal parts, then thin or strip it for the job. This is the pantry math worth keeping.
Cook's notes

What should you know before making honey mustard?

History

Where did honey mustard come from?

Mustard sweetened with honey goes back at least to Roman kitchens, mel and mustum shared shelves for centuries. The American dip-counter version, mayo-bound and squeeze-bottled, is a 1980s fast-food canonization of a very old idea.

Derivatives

What can you make from honey mustard?

Dressing
Base plus 1 tbsp cider vinegar and 2 tbsp olive oil, whisked or shaken.
Glaze
Honey and Dijon only, equal parts, brushed on in the final minutes of heat.
Hot honey mustard
A tablespoon of hot sauce or a half teaspoon of cayenne, the wing-adjacent version.
FAQ

Common questions.

What mustard is best for honey mustard?

Dijon is the standard, sharp and smooth. Yellow makes it milder and more nostalgic, coarse-grain adds texture, hot English turns up the burn. Blending Dijon with a spoonful of yellow is the crowd-pleaser.

Can I make honey mustard without mayo?

Yes, honey and mustard alone make the glaze version, add Greek yogurt instead of mayo for a tangier dip that holds up nutritionally.

How long does homemade honey mustard keep?

Two weeks refrigerated in a sealed jar, all three main ingredients are already shelf-stable, the lemon and any yogurt swap set the clock.

Kyle Schulgen Founder, Speakeater
Builder of Speakeater, the cooking app that reads your fridge. Writes the recipe reference pages by hand, anchored in public-domain culinary sources.
Last updated: 2026-05-29

Open your fridge. We'll figure out dinner.

Speakeater reads what you already have and tells you what to cook, sauce included. Photo your shelf, get a recipe back.

Save me a seat